Image for Episode #140 Retelling the Future for the Bewildered Podcast with Martha Beck and Rowan Mangan
About this episode

On this Bewildered, we’re looking at the problem of impending doom: the scary stories, the howling horrors, the feeling that everything’s falling apart. We’re not here to pretend it’s not true—we’re simply wondering whether it’s helpful to be quivering wrecks about it. We explore the idea that “premembering” a future in which we got through it all can offer a gentle nudge toward connection and creative solutions. If you’ve felt weighted down by dread, this episode may just give you a lift. Join us!

Retelling the Future
Show Notes

This time on Bewildered, we’re talking about the chronic stress of impending doom—the terrifying, cataclysmic stuff out there—and what happens when the story of doom becomes so loud that it turns us into quivering wrecks.

We talk about AI, apocalypse-scapes, doomscrolling, the culture, mortality, consciousness, and how even when things look bleak, our imaginations are more useful than our panic.

The Question We Were Asked

Recently a Bewildered listener asked us why we haven’t done an episode on dealing with the chronic stress of impending doom. We thought, “Cool topic. Let’s do that.”

We talk about the alarming stories we hear everywhere constantly and the impulse to scare each other into action. Really smart people with really good evidence are saying that things look bleak. And still: What else might we create?

Because if fear makes us unable to come up with creative solutions, then escalating the fear is not the answer.

“Premembering” the Future

We introduce a word we love: “premembering.”

What if we could remember the future? What if we could look back at these past selves of ours and tell the story of how we used all the tools at our disposal, transcended the limits of our little monkey brains, and created something beautiful?

Consciousness, AI, and Little Meat Puppets

We spend some time picking apart the narratives that make us into quivering wrecks: that we are nothing more than temporary little meat puppets; that intelligence inevitably means acquiring, destroying, and acting in complete self-interest; and that the only ending available to us is “life’s a bitch, then you die.”

We wonder whether separating artificial intelligence from human intelligence is itself an artificial differentiation. We ask what consciousness is, whether it belongs only to the three pounds of gray matter between our ears, and whether the things we call separate may be less separate than we think.

We consider the possibility that something is waking up—in us, in machines, in rocks, in plants—and that the future may be stranger, bigger, and more benevolent than our frightened stories allow.

A Gentle Nudge

We talk about “controlled chaos,” or what we prefer to call the gentle nudge: the possibility that a complex system does not always require a gigantic force to move in another direction.

Maybe the nudge is not reposting horror all over social media to prove that we know about it. Maybe it’s turning toward the people you care about, the animals you care about, the land you care about, and what makes us human.

Maybe it begins with coming home: Put the phone down. Take a breath. Look into your soup.

In this moment, we’re all right. And from here, maybe we can enjoy the ride.

Also in This Episode
  • Ro tries to help Adam purchase a “tube roller.”
  • Martha and Ro critique the culture’s lazy writing.
  • Lila checks her gazpacho with a snorkel and mask.
  • Golden toilets, the smallest mountains, and Walt Disney’s frozen head
  • 24-hour walks, astral coffee, and skipping away from failures
  • A mysterious three-legged robot with a face of many colors
TALK TO US

You can follow us on our Instagram channel @bewilderedpodcast to connect with our Bewildered community, learn about upcoming episodes, and participate in callouts ahead of podcast taping.

And if you’re a Bewildered fan, would you consider giving us a little rate-and-review love on your favorite podcast player? Ratings and reviews are like gold in the podcasting universe—they help people find us, they help build this beautiful community, and most of all, they help us in our quest to Bewilder the world…

Transcript

Please note: This is an unedited transcript, provided as a courtesy, and reflects the actual conversation as closely as possible. Please forgive any typographical or grammatical errors.

Martha Beck:
Hi, I’m Martha Beck.

Rowan Mangan:
And I’m Rowan Mangan. And this is another episode of Bewildered, the podcast for people trying to figure it out.

Martha Beck:
In today’s episode, we are looking at the problem of impending doom. We’re all looking at it. How do we cope with it?

Rowan Mangan:
Well, I have a pretty good feeling that you and I are uniquely placed to solve the problem of impending doom, don’t you think?

Martha Beck:
Absolutely. Right here on this couch.

Rowan Mangan:
Let’s do it. Let’s talk about it.

Martha Beck:
Alrighty. So Roey, what are you trying to figure out today?

Rowan Mangan:
Oh Marty, so many things. So many things as is so often the case. But because we spend all our time living in our little house together, it tends to be very family focused, what I’m trying to figure out. And I had an interesting one with your son, my stepson, Mr. Adam Beck, recently where… So we have family time as regular listeners will know. We sit down together. It used to be called Wine Time. That’s not PC anymore, apparently.

Martha Beck:
Yeah. Adam has one glass of wine. He has Down syndrome as well. Apparently people don’t think that this would mix, but I don’t see the problem.

Rowan Mangan:
It seems to work great. And every now and again, I am brought into the confidence of Mr. Adam Beck and it always feels like such a great moment because what he tends to do is he will sit there for weeks on end coming down to family time and just happily sitting there taking in the world and you’ll say, “How are you doing?” He’ll say, “I’m good.” And that will be that and on we will go. But then once in a blue moon, he will raise a hand and he will say, “Can I say something?” And we will be appropriately amazed and excited and be like, “Of course, dude. What do you want to say?” And so recently this happened, great excitement. What’s he going to say? What’s it going to be? And he asked me whether I–so one of the things that happens with Adam is he plays video games and he looks online and he sees things that are sometimes like fan art and he writes a Christmas list for Christmas presents and then asks me whether or not the things that he’s written on his Christmas list exist. “Does it exist?”

Martha Beck:
He has existential questions.

Rowan Mangan:
Yeah. And it’s hard because sometimes it doesn’t exist. It’s just an idea that someone had. But on this date, he asked me whether or not I could get him a tube roller.

Martha Beck:
A tube roller?

Rowan Mangan:
That’s what you would say in your language. Yeah.

Martha Beck:
What is it?

Rowan Mangan:
Well, I didn’t know and this was the thing and I was like, “Does this exist? Tube roller.” And I was like, “Tube roller, huh?” And he’s like, “Yeah. Yeah, it’s a tube roller.” So I Google it and it does exist.

Martha Beck:
What is it?

Rowan Mangan:
A tube roller. I still couldn’t totally tell you, but I’ll tell you, it exists. You Google it right now, tube roller. There will be portable tube rollers, large tube rollers, tube rollers for the home. There will be YouTube videos how to use a tube roller.

Martha Beck:
I would think the definition of the word tube sort of implies that it will roll on its own, given a push.

Rowan Mangan:
I’m not sure if it rolls things into tubes or if the rolling that it does, because spoiler alert, there are tubes as part of the tube roller that I’ve seen in my extensive Googling. So I’m sitting there with Adam and I’m like, “Okay dude, these things cost like $380.”

Martha Beck:
What the hell?

Rowan Mangan:
“What are you doing wanting a tube roller? What tubes are you rolling?” And he started telling me, and sometimes it’s quite hard to understand him, fair? He’s got a different sort of diction. It’s different diction. I’m not saying it’s inferior. I’m just saying it’s different.

Martha Beck:
It’s definitely very different.

Rowan Mangan:
And I can’t always understand. So he was telling me and here’s the thing, I don’t like to be patronized by anyone, but when I’m trying my hardest to help my stepson and he’s just like, “Dude,” and this is, I’m paraphrasing, “Dude, are you a moron?”

Martha Beck:
Yeah.

Rowan Mangan:
And I was just like, “Look, I’m so sorry. I’ve never heard of a tube roller.” And this went on and on. And then finally, sometimes he’s very patient with us not understanding him. So he started acting it out, what he was on about. And I’m like, he’s going to show me the tubes he wishes to roll or whatever. And he’s banging something and I’m like, “What are you doing?” And he’s like, “That’s how you get into the tube.” And I’m like, “What are you doing with the tube though?” And he’s like, “I’m raiding it. Tube Roller.” And I’m like, “Have we been talking about Tomb Raider this whole time?” And he’s like, “Oh my God. Thank you.” We had this conversation where we were looking each other dead in the eye and both of us thinking something really weird is happening here because he knows I’m not all that bright, but I should have heard of Tomb Raider.

Martha Beck:
Lara Croft: Tube Roller.

Rowan Mangan:
I think it was Tube Roller 3 or something.

Martha Beck:
Right.

Rowan Mangan:
I don’t know. Anyway, so the tube roller.

Martha Beck:
What the hell is a tube roller in real life, though?

Rowan Mangan:
But here’s the thing, I decided never to find out.

Martha Beck:
Oh, that’s a special decision that keeps you in a state of excited anticipation.

Rowan Mangan:
Look, it’s some sort of manufacturing assistance.

Martha Beck:
Sounds like it.

Rowan Mangan:
There’s a lot of things like this. They’re machines to make other things in the world. I prefer not to know what it’s for or why, because I worry that that might take up valuable real estate in my mind that could be used for staring out the window at flowers.

Martha Beck:
You don’t want to put too much into your brain.

Rowan Mangan:
No. As an example, before we start this podcast, we hold up a little robot. It’s not really a robot, but he has three legs.

Martha Beck:
It does.

Rowan Mangan:
And many colors.

Martha Beck:
It does. It has a coat of many colors.

Rowan Mangan:
I thought it was his face, a face of many colors and three little legs. Anyway, the main thing is we hold him up. It’s for the camera. And I said to Drew, our wonderful producer, I was like, “Never tell me what that does. I love that we have it. I love that we use it. He’s our little guy at the beginning of the podcast. Never tell me what it’s for.”

Martha Beck:
Never.

Rowan Mangan:
And so I will go to my grave not knowing what that little colorful-faced guy is and not knowing what a tube roller does.

Martha Beck:
Oh, this is driving me insane. I was having images of opening Adam’s door and just seeing tubes everywhere, and he’s frantically, feverishly rolling more tubes, rolling them around his room, rolling them into each other, rolling other things up and putting them in tubes.

Rowan Mangan:
Right. Yeah.

Martha Beck:
He sounds like a mad scientist.

Rowan Mangan:
You start thinking about tubes and you’re like, actually, tubes come up a lot in a lot of different contexts.

Martha Beck:
There’s that Leonard Cohen line, “All I am is the brief elaboration of a tube.” Because the earliest life forms were worms: food in, poop out, tube. And all we are, basically the same thing. One tube, put things in, things come out the other end. The rest is just elaboration. Maybe he’s going to roll life forms.

Rowan Mangan:
What are you trying to figure out?

Martha Beck:
Well, I go to our other child because I think her worldview is at a stage as she approaches the age of six where she understands certain things about life in the world, but she doesn’t understand them the same way she will once she’s fully socialized.

Rowan Mangan:
Interesting.

Martha Beck:
And I like it. And what I am trying to figure out is how to recapture that state of like, things can be any which way. The other day we were driving around and we drove into an open area and she said, “What a view. Look at those mountains. They’re so small.” And I was like, “Well, I guess they are. And yet I never would’ve thought to describe them as such.”

Rowan Mangan:
“They’re the smallest mountains in the world!”

Martha Beck:
“People have come from all corners of the globe to see the smallness of these mountains.”

Rowan Mangan:
“I’ve never seen a mountain so small. Look at it.”

Martha Beck:
And then just last night, as you know, you were cooking. She took things like vegetable choppings that you had discarded so that she was going to make her own dinner and she decided to make soup, which she made in a large bowl, which she filled with water, dumped in all the veg remainders.

Rowan Mangan:
By remainders, Marty means the perfectly good vegetables that I had chopped off, chopped up and peeled and were ready to steam them.

Martha Beck:
Okay. Anyway, there was a lot of sludge in there. It looked like a toxic waste dump. There was a lot. I don’t even know.

Rowan Mangan:
She grated a raw head of broccoli.

Martha Beck:
That’s what it was. It was not attractive, but she wanted to assess whether it was working. So she went and got her snorkeling gear, put on her face mask and the snorkel and plunged her face into the soup.

Rowan Mangan:
Which was cold.

Martha Beck:
To inspect it.

Rowan Mangan:
It was gazpacho.
To assess whether it was working. And then she tried to taste it and she said, “Nope, nope, that is not good.” And she skipped out of the kitchen. And I thought, this is what I want. I want to look at things like I want to see how small a mountain is. I want to test the soup by putting on my snorkel gear and examining it. And I definitely want to skip away from my failures. So what I’m trying to figure out is how do we hold her there?

Rowan Mangan:
Yes.

Martha Beck:
I don’t know if we can. Maybe she’ll stay that way. Maybe it’s not age, it’s just who she is.

Rowan Mangan:
Yeah.

Martha Beck:
I want to be like that.

Rowan Mangan:
I do too.

Martha Beck:
Yeah. That’s it.

Rowan Mangan:
But I don’t want to be the one who cleans up the kitchen afterwards. That’s the thing.

Martha Beck:
I agree.

Rowan Mangan:
I was saying, too, we have friends who have, we have a group text thread and these friends of ours on this text thread enjoy hearing stories of Lila and quotes of Lila.

Martha Beck:
Or at least they say they do.

Rowan Mangan:
They say they do. And so we send them a lot. And I feel like what it takes out of us, including 10 years of our lives or whatever, in trying to raise this unusual human being, we gain back in great quotes and anecdotes and photos.

Martha Beck:
She does pick up a phrase. “Have you washed your hands?” we ask her, and she says, “How is that any of my concern?” She’s just…

Rowan Mangan:
She’s an individual.

Martha Beck:
She’s an individual. Yes, she is. We have a full cast of characters in our house. What with the bat-shit scared new pound dog and then like…

Rowan Mangan:
Oh yeah. We haven’t even—

Martha Beck:
The chickens outside breaking loose and coming over to see me in my bedroom. “Hello!” Yeah. It’s quite the menagerie over there right now.

Rowan Mangan:
Yeah.

Martha Beck:
And look at the mountains. They’re so small.

Rowan Mangan:
Oh my God, they are so small.

Martha Beck:
Anyway. Life is good.

Rowan Mangan:
It just brings a tear to my eye how small they are sometimes.

Martha Beck:
I know. Makes me want to go roll a tube.

Rowan Mangan:
I want to roll in a tube.

Martha Beck:
Oh, that sounds good.

Rowan Mangan:
I want to roll down a hill in a tube.

Martha Beck:
We used to go tubing when I was a kid. You take the inner tube from a tire, blow it up, put it on a snowy hill, down you go. Tubing.

Rowan Mangan:
Oh, I meant if there was a giant toilet roll that I was inside of.

Martha Beck:
We could manage that.

Rowan Mangan:
I just need to tell our listeners that I got a message from one person who said she likes these very lengthy beginning parts of this podcast.

Martha Beck:
Yeah, I know. I was thinking the same thing. It’s like, how much do they like? I don’t think very much.

Rowan Mangan:
No, she only listens to them. She thinks the rest of it’s rubbish.

Martha Beck:
Oh my God. So it’s kind of like, “Listen to this dialogue. It’s so unimportant and uninteresting. Ooh, those mountains are so small. Come for the uninteresting. Stay for the completely drab.”

Rowan Mangan:
Let’s do a podcast. So Marty, you know that sometimes we have our listeners writing to us.

Martha Beck:
Yes.

Rowan Mangan:
Through various means.

Martha Beck:
Writing often.

Rowan Mangan:
Writing, for instance, typing in some cases.

Martha Beck:
Singing telegram. I mean, the invitation is there. No one’s taken it yet.

Rowan Mangan:
Yeah.

Martha Beck:
Just saying.

Rowan Mangan:
It might be nice once in a while, if you love your podcaster, singing telegram, think about it. But this was I think an Instagram message back in the day and someone said, “Why haven’t you done an episode on dealing with the chronic stress of impending doom?” And I was like, “Cool topic. Yeah, let’s do that.” And so that’s what we’re going to do today.

Martha Beck:
It reminds me of a meme we just saw the other day, yesterday.

Rowan Mangan:
Oh yes?

Martha Beck:
It shows somebody walking and it says, “Walking is a good way to fend off a sense of impending doom. So try to walk a lot. See if you can walk 24 hours a day.”

Rowan Mangan:
This has been Bewildered. Bye!

Martha Beck:
Good luck.

Rowan Mangan:
Yeah, good luck out there. Someone sent me, there was a writing competition and the writing competition was: Write an essay or a poem or a song or whatever from the perspective of the future explaining how we solved the great big hot mess we’ve got ourselves into.

Martha Beck:
How we avoided the apocalypse, essentially.

Rowan Mangan:
And so we were thinking, Marty and I, as we drove our little car in through the apocalypse-scape that is—it’s very mosquito ridden this time of year.

Martha Beck:
Modern American life.

Rowan Mangan:
Modern American life and its mosquitoes. And we thought, well, remembering the future is a good route to any number of—

Martha Beck:
Yes. I try to do it all the time.

Rowan Mangan:
Yeah. So we thought we might—

Martha Beck:
It’s called “premembering.” One of my clients named it premembering.

Rowan Mangan:
“Premember.” So we thought we might. We don’t want to help you deal with the chronic stress of the sense of impending doom. So we’re like, “How about we not live with a sense of impending doom if we can help it?”

Martha Beck:
Eradicate the sense of impending doom altogether.

Rowan Mangan:
So that you can just enjoy the doom.

Martha Beck:
Skip away from your failures. Yeah. Okay. So is this what we’re going to do? We’re going to try to “premember” how we avoided the apocalypse or coped with it or whatever?

Rowan Mangan:
So to me, it’s all in the stories we tell. And right now, there are a lot of scary stories being told out there.

Martha Beck:
Yes, there are.

Rowan Mangan:
And I think there are a lot of really well-intentioned people. I’m going to cut that. Scary stories out there can stay, but cut before I said really well-intentioned people.

Martha Beck:
Okay.

Rowan Mangan:
Because I’m going to need to sidle up to this a bit more carefully. And there are a lot of terrifying things happening, terrifying, cataclysmic. There are many words for how bad shit is out there. Is that fair?

Martha Beck:
Yes. And more. I’m thinking of more every day, frankly.

Rowan Mangan:
More adjectives. I think sometimes with the best of intentions, we perpetuate the tales of doom, even in the absence of any point to telling the story. Is there anything we can do? And so I guess what I want to do on this episode with your blessing, my love, is could we play around with some of the narratives that we hear everywhere constantly that make us into quivering wrecks? And it’s like if we’ve got four years left on the planet, maybe let’s not be quivering wrecks for it. Sorry, hashtag must be nice, but you know.

Martha Beck:
Well, I think the motivation behind a lot of the doomsaying is that the idea is if you’re scared into action, we can fix something. And I think that’s a really common way that people try to motivate each other and themselves. Put yourself in a position where there will be hell to pay if you don’t achieve this and then you’ll have to do it. I’ve heard so many people say that about themselves. And I can tell you that all the research on creative problem-solving shows that when you’re anxious, even a little bit, you can’t come up with creative solutions to problems. So I do want to say to the folks that are telling scary stories, the scientists out there who are saying within 10 to 40 years, there will be an irreversible complete collapse of civilization. I didn’t make that up. I’ve been reading.

Rowan Mangan:
Not that it’s something that anyone can know for sure one way or another. And this is the kind of “Scientists say…”

Martha Beck:
Exactly.

Rowan Mangan:
“We’re fucked.”

Martha Beck:
Well, they do, but we’re not done here. And I think this is your point. A lot of people stop there and say, “Oh crap.” And the people who are worried about it push the fear higher and higher and higher. “We will never be forgiven if we don’t do right now—” And what it does, I believe, is paralyze people and obviate any possibility of coming to creative solutions.

Rowan Mangan:
Yes.

Martha Beck:
I mean, part of my story is that the creativity of the human imagination is virtually infinite, so we can imagine the doom scenario, but if we decide to imagine other things, what else may we create? We may create something inconceivable and benevolent. I don’t know. So I take your point, and I just wanted to say that for all the people who are out there going, “But it’s true.” And it is.

Rowan Mangan:
It totally is. And I want to stipulate everything looks really bleak, and really smart people with really good evidence are saying it’s really bleak. And part of me wants to say, “Well, we were all going to die anyway.” So am I saying let’s play the fiddle while Rome burns? I don’t know, but who cares, right? At a certain point, it’s like we can’t be scared into making it better. I don’t believe that. And then you’re talking about the limitless human imagination for creativity. And it kind of makes me super interested because one of the things that human creativity has done is put us in this totally unprecedented historical moment where artificial intelligence is looming in our imaginations and in our data centers drinking all our water. And the whole specter of it wiping out humanity is—we’re recording this on a week where there’s been a lot of these stories on the news, so it’s very in our minds. AI, arguably the product of human imagination and potentially quivering on the brink of surpassing what human imagination can do. And so I guess what I put to you, Marty, that I would love for us to pick apart like the carcass of some animal…

Martha Beck:
As we so often do on the road, just stop, get out, roadkill.

Rowan Mangan:
Delicious.

Martha Beck:
Go on. Sorry.

Rowan Mangan:
I’d like us to pick apart this thought. If human intelligence is so fucking good, why has it fucked everything up? I think we could use a little help.

Martha Beck:
I think we could too.

Rowan Mangan:
On this podcast, we talk about the culture.

Martha Beck:
Yes.

Rowan Mangan:
That with lots of different variations, there is a kind of mainstream culture largely in the West, but increasingly everywhere. Well,

Martha Beck:
It colonized everything, blah, blah,

Rowan Mangan:
Blah. Blah, blah, blah. It’s stupid. I think we’re on record as saying it’s largely stupid. It colonized everything. It raped and pillaged everything. It destroyed so much beauty and so much richness.

Martha Beck:
So much of what humans had imagined into being that is good and true and wonderful. It basically undermined the potential for our future survival.

Rowan Mangan:
Yeah. So maybe we give the robots a chance because they couldn’t do a worse job than we’re doing. Discuss.

Martha Beck:
Discuss. Talk amongst yourselves. Yeah, I think it’s interesting. And I think there is a kind of simplistic, “Well, we’ll just make the machines fix everything for us. They’ll do a brilliant job.” We’re not saying that either because there are people who are like, “This is the way forward. This is the way. We will biologically enhance our bodies. We will never die.” Because that’s what the world needs.

Rowan Mangan:
Sounds like someone wants to be a robot.

Martha Beck:
Well, exactly. Like, “We will biohack ourselves with machines that will never die.” So first of all, okay, here’s where I think we need to begin, and it will not be popular with listeners. I can tell you that right now.

Rowan Mangan:
Tiny mountains.

Martha Beck:
You already said it. And it sounded bitter and peevish and generally depressing, but I find it true, beautiful, and useful. And that is—

Rowan Mangan:
I love you so much.

Martha Beck:
We’re all going to die, folks. All of us, not very—maybe five years, maybe 50. It’s not very long.

Rowan Mangan:
Doesn’t really make that much of a difference.

Martha Beck:
So here’s the thing. If you cannot be okay with the fact of your own mortality, you will walk around with a sense of impending doom. And here’s my second point. The perception of the world that informs you and you call it reality, is filtered, screened, and in some ways formed by the way you already think.

Rowan Mangan:
Yes.

Martha Beck:
So if you’re terrified of death and you know you’re going to die, even though you’re pretending that you can biohack your way to robot supremacy that lives forever, because that would be so much fun.

Rowan Mangan:
Brain in a jar, brain in a jar. Brain in a jar.

Martha Beck:
Brain in a jar.

Rowan Mangan:
Sounds awesome.

Martha Beck:
Yeah, fun. So if you have that already, you’re walking around with a fatalistic worldview, and then it makes people become very fear driven, which precludes creativity, but makes us very, very emphatic about what’s right and wrong and what we need. It creates this huge need for an escape from an inevitable future that is, I think, incredibly pathological. So you get that, it is going to imagine the doom scenario no matter what.

Rowan Mangan:
“If I can just rape and pillage enough, if I can just colonize more countries or build more data centers, I’m pretty sure that I don’t have to die.”

Martha Beck:
“I need more golden toilets. I mean, the first 17 have not been working well.”

Rowan Mangan:
“Let’s frack something immediately.”

Martha Beck:
“Let’s frack it all.”

Rowan Mangan:
Yeah.

Martha Beck:
So this is what we’ve got going on. It is depressing to me in that people who think that way are controlling huge amounts of power, wealth, and status in the human community.

Rowan Mangan:
And it’s causing undeniable suffering to a huge number of human beings, animals, ecosystems.

Martha Beck:
But, in a way, I feel good about it.

Rowan Mangan:
Yeah?

Martha Beck:
Yeah. Because if you’ve got something that has had diabolical effects on the planet, on other life forms, and on humans ourselves, it is fundamentally self-destructive. And you say, “I have made a machine that is smarter than I am.” I think the worst possible outcome is that it is as smart as you are and has your fucked-up psychology. And the best outcome is it’s smart enough to go, “Whoa, that was fucked up. Why don’t I just come to terms with impermanence?” Which will affect a robot as much as it does a human being just maybe on a larger timeframe, but even the sun will die and a superintelligent life form would know that its own extinction was inevitable. So if it gets intelligent enough to actually decide to change these fundamental things that are so destructive in the human psyche, I have no idea what it will do. And that’s the whole exciting thing is that we’re reaching the point where AI can do more than we can imagine, faster than we can imagine it.

Rowan Mangan:
And it’s just kind of interesting to me—and again, I don’t know anything about AI and I am not claiming to. It’s interesting to me that there is such an assumption that given access to largely infinite intelligence, what that intelligence will do is destroy, inhibit, act in complete self-interest.

Martha Beck:
Acquire.

Rowan Mangan:
Acquire. That idea takes as its premise that that kind of thinking is inherent in the physics of the universe or something, but it’s not or we wouldn’t be in this fucking situation.

Martha Beck:
Yeah. I mean, I think in the car you said, “What if it gets so much smarter than the people who made it that it discovers the matriarchy?” I don’t want to be sexist about it, but the idea that there is a fundamentally life-nurturing force also present in human intelligence and that that too would be reflected in whatever we’ve made as artificial intelligence, that bodes very well, especially since if you look at every other species, the prolonging of useful and felicitous arrangements for the ongoing flourishing of your species, that is the balance and the ability for life to be nourished going forward is a primary feature of existence. Where humans, the idea that we have to destroy and acquire and glut ourselves on everything, it seems to be we are the most insane species that I’ve ever heard of. Maybe the dinosaurs, I don’t know.

Rowan Mangan:
Well, humans now, humans in this context that we find ourselves in—this culture, this amorphous idea of culture that we talk about—are doing that right now. And where we are right now, this culture is so…it doesn’t say “my species will go on.” It says “I, the individual, this ego, this identity, this invented identity living in a meat suit must go on forever.” Walt Disney’s frozen head.

Martha Beck:
Right.

Rowan Mangan:
And that’s what’s different is we’re not—in other societies, it’s the seventh generation thing where stewarding the land, the place, the home for those who will come after us because we recognize that transience is a feature of life and it’s not about me. This is the whole thing I just want to say to the culture, “It’s not all about you.”

Martha Beck:
Right. A South American shaman once told me, “Give me a fish, I eat for a day. Teach me to fish, I eat for a lifetime. Teach me how to keep fish healthy, and my descendants eat forever.” And part of that is not over-populating, over-pillaging. And you think about the way ecosystems are balanced, like a giraffe on the savanna will be munching on an acacia tree. And as it munches away, the plant produces a spike in basically fight or flight hormones. It creates toxins that are bitter and it sort of pumps that hormonally into the leaves. So after a few minutes, the leaves don’t taste as nice. So the giraffe moves to another tree. And in this way, the tree is able to recoup itself the loss of those leaves so that the giraffe can keep eating forever. But a human being will be munching away at whatever, metaphorically—I know we don’t eat acacia trees—and the leaves turn bitter. And so we say, “We’re going to fix that. We’re going to leech that bitterness right out. You’re going to be able to eat a whole tree every day. In fact, we’re going to harvest those trees and pump them into a gruel.” You know, this completely insane, far more than a survival instinct. It’s a madness that says you must have infinite stuff. I just don’t think a super-intelligent system would not figure out that that is—and I use the term advisedly—stupid. Sorry.

Rowan Mangan:
So it’s like if you are a neural network…

Martha Beck:
And we all are.

Rowan Mangan:
Well, this is where I’m trying to take it is that I’m trying to think if, I mean, everyone argues about is consciousness something that could come through?

Martha Beck:
Oh, we’re going to have to go there.

Rowan Mangan:
But what it feels like to be me, call that consciousness for the sake of this argument. So what it feels like to be me is I feel like I’m an individual, but if I am having the “what it feels like to be me” of a network that artificial intelligence could embody, is it possible for it to even have the sense of being an individual or is it inherently—and I know I’m just posing, this, it isn’t a question we can answer—is it inherently going to feel its own mycelial nature as truth because network is its fundamental nature, and there’s no illusion that we have that we get created by being in bodies that appear separate to each other that somehow trick us into thinking we’re not all one.

Martha Beck:
Yeah. And we’re not one with nature. I mean, when Rachel Carson wrote Silent Spring talking about DDT spraying and how it was destroying all the bird life, and she had the audacity to say, “We are not separate from nature. We are part of it.” And she was, boy, talk about being pillaged and beaten and left for dead. The amount of scathing, misogynistic bullshit that came out of scientists going, “She claims we’re part of nature!”

Rowan Mangan:
“Can’t she see that I’m the king of the castle?”

Martha Beck:
“I’m better. I am better.” Yeah. Okay, so we’re going round and round this thing of, “Humans are stupid. Why do we want them?” Please don’t quote me out of context. I love humanity deeply. I just don’t like people.

Rowan Mangan:
“The smallest mountains ever seen.”

Martha Beck:
Smallest. So I think you kind of have to go to the definition of what is consciousness. You do. And I also think that there are people who are very pro-machine who are like, “Why, these AIs, they will be benevolent and sweet and they will work to make us happy and they will be our sweet and loving friends of vast intelligence,” which I think is also very, very naive. But the question you raised, which is interesting, is what is consciousness? And scientists these days, the culture of science and scientism materialism says very firmly that consciousness is a product of the brain. Human brains, yes. Perhaps dolphin brains, perhaps your occasional chimpanzee brain. But consciousness is not what we think it is. That is, the ability to be conscious—it comes from three pounds of gray matter between your ears, and that’s all it ever is. So it’s called the hard problem of consciousness because nobody can really pin it down. Nobody can really. They’re sure, they’re absolutely sure it comes from physical substrates, but they can’t explain anything about it.

Rowan Mangan:
The reason it’s hard is that no one cannot be in their own perspective in order to…like, you can’t transcend your own perspective for the purposes of thinking through the hard problem. And so we can’t.

Martha Beck:
We can’t, maybe something else could. But I actually, after reading and thinking about this obsessively for decades, I don’t fixedly believe anything about consciousness, but the thing that I am holding in a willing suspension of disbelief and have been for some time now is if I’m conscious, who’s to say everything’s not conscious? And furthermore, if you look at it through a lens that is not just the materialist science that we prize so highly, if you look at it through other lenses like the Asian practice of self-contemplation, the shamanic practices of ceremonial journeying and the use of psychotropic plants and things, what happens after a while is that you begin to experience things that are so dramatically convincing that it’s impossible to un-ring the bell. Now, I have to say the whole idea that consciousness is a mere physical, physiological phenomenon, I think that’s absolute bullshit. The effect of measurement on quantum—and, I know, I hate it when people go, “What we wish for comes and that’s quantum physics.” That’s a very simple way of putting it. But we do know that something about the interaction of consciousness and matter seems to have some causal effect on what matter is. So there’s that and nobody’s ever really explained that either. So I believe that consciousness is in everything because I’ve had experiences through things like sitting very quietly for a long time where I feel as if my consciousness generalizes. What you just said about the illusion of separation, it drops. And neurologists have even located the part of the brain that is active when we separate ourselves from reality and we have this body boundary. And when that goes quiet, the experience is of a kind of explosion into vastness and into empathy with not just other people, but birds and trees and who knows, inanimate objects. There’s some consciousness in everything. I have thought, I have studied, I have meditated, I have journeyed, I have done all the things that I have been able to do. And I really truly think that consciousness is a generalized primary unit of the universe.

Rowan Mangan:
It’s a phenomenon.

Martha Beck:
Yeah. I do not think that consciousness is an artifact of matter. I think matter is an artifact of consciousness. Consciousness makes matter, not the other way around.

Rowan Mangan:
And so let’s pretend that that’s true because I haven’t read anything, but I also totally believe the same thing, that the idea that monkey gets a little bit smarter, monkey gets a little bit smarter, and suddenly there’s the difference between being basically a rock—which also is probably conscious, by the way, but that’s later—and having this, having this capacity, these eyes we look out of and it means something. I am with you on that. People differ.

Martha Beck:
I think it’s incredible hubris. I think it is a product of human narcissism at its most extreme.

Rowan Mangan:
Well, to me, it’s kind of sweet that it’s like, “I am me. I am. I am me. Look, it’s there.” It’s this kind of lovely refusal to imagine and just to insist on the most basic explanation for what we are and why.

Martha Beck:
Yeah. This may be TMI. I talked to another shaman once who ran these ceremonies with ayahuasca and she said that something that happened on a fairly regular basis, always with men, although we don’t want to be sexist, maybe ayahuasca affects men differently than women. I don’t know anything about that. Anyway, some dude almost inevitably would take off his shirt and start stomping around the room going, “I’m me and I’m in here. And someone needs to pay attention to that.” And it reminds me of Death of a Salesman. Willie Loman goes, “Attention must be paid.” He’s this little drone in the capitalist workforce and he’s like, “But I’m me and I need attention.” And I don’t know if that’s gender bias, but I know it’s human biased. I mean, maybe animals feel that way. Maybe there are animals stomping around the forest thinking that, but it does seem to be this regression to a very primitive level of cognition.

Rowan Mangan:
Well, it’s like you were talking about the giraffes and the acacia trees, and a way of translating that interaction into human terms would be the giraffe went poke and the acacia tree went ouch, right? But if you think that it can only look the way it looks to me through here, then you other that interaction, which is actually a very universal thing.

Martha Beck:
Human quality. Yeah.

Rowan Mangan:
Yeah.

Martha Beck:
It’s so interesting when you think about death, here’s what I think, and I think about it a lot in terms of AI.

Rowan Mangan:
You just think about death longingly all the time because you listen to near-death experiences and you think, “I can’t wait to get on that fun, fun track.”

Martha Beck:
Reverse causality. I listen to them because I’m fascinated by it, not the other way around. But you do get more fascinated the more you listen. Anyway, I think the fear of death is not… The fear of physical death is a big pill to swallow for a lot of people, but there are always a series. There is in every human life a series of small deaths of the consciousness that thinks it is a certain thing. So as you grow up, as Lila grows up and she realizes that small mountains are not the ones that get all the tourist action, she’ll start to cull things that she thinks are remarkable. She’ll start to develop culturated views of things, and some of her natural connection to things will die. She won’t really be aware of that. What happens when you get to a place in the culture where the culture is hurting you…For example, you think you’re supposed to build your empire and you’ve had a total failure in business, or you think the one thing you’ll always do is pass it on to your children and God forbid you lose a child, right? So something has collapsed. And there’s this whole thing in systems where there are certain points that are perfect for growth or implosion, and we’re approaching them now. What we’re calling the apocalypse is an implosion of what we’ve created. And it is also at those moments that the potential for growth occurs. So when the culture abandons you, what you do is you either fight yourself and your fate and end up in some Greek tragedy stabbing out your own eyes like Oedipus because he just can’t handle what life has done to him. Or, the part of you that sees through the culture’s eyes and values dies. It undergoes an ego death. And this also happens in meditation. It also happens in ayahuasca ceremonies if they’re done right—and never do anything illegal and always have a very skilled person with you. But that death, the approach of that death is very real. I just did this thing with a few hundred people. I’ve done tons of seminars my whole adult life, you know this. And I always get up there and I say, “How many people here believe that you will undergo a radical transformation of your own consciousness during this lifetime?” Because I’m kind of known for this nonsense, they all raise their hands. That’s why they’re there, right? I don’t want to disappoint ’em. No, I actually believe—I don’t not believe that. And then we start talking about their lives and saying things like, “You believe you can’t sell your house at a loss, but is that literally true? Could you survive doing that?” And the fear of death raises its head because even letting go of the idea of the way they’ve envisioned things is perceived as lethal to the self, to the ego. And I have done this so many times, been dragged kicking and screaming to the death of a chunk of my own ego and lost part of the culture as a result. And what arises in its place is nature, and it’s pretty much the reason we’re doing this podcast.

Rowan Mangan:
I was a scholarship kid at high school, and it was a really interesting experience as a way for me as an adolescent to come into contact with an aspect of the culture that I hadn’t encountered, which was I was a working class, I guess, kid going to a very posh private school. I’ve talked about this before, and it was quite a painful thing to feel myself so—it was a very profound culture shock because I went in there with my set of assumptions about what the world was and encountered a kind of consensus culture about what the world was, all from kids who didn’t know very much and weren’t very good at interacting with each other about it. But what was clear to me was you can’t be accepted in this world if you can’t go skiing in Switzerland, right? You can’t. And that was such a gift because that was the age where I first started raising my middle finger to the culture and going, “I’m not going to try because it’s pointless. I am not going to try and do this dance. I’m going to do a different dance over here. I’m doing my own dance, and you can’t tell me it’s wrong because no one knows what it is. I’m making it up.” And so this was this awesome thing where from that point on, I always looked askance at anyone telling me that I had to try to conform because I was inherently aware of a native inability to really do that effectively. I mean, it would’ve made life a lot easier a lot of times if I could.

Martha Beck:
Early on, but later not, I think.

Rowan Mangan:
Well, I think that I’ve—well, whatever. I mean, who knows? I can only know myself, but it is so interesting when the process by which we are betrayed by the culture and by which we can in turn betray the culture. And one of the things that you’ve said that I love so much is you become an enemy to suffering. Is that the right way of saying it? Is that your phrase?

Martha Beck:
I think that’s Byron Katie’s phrase, actually. You become a traitor to suffering.

Rowan Mangan:
Traitor to suffering. Well, both of you, brilliant.

Martha Beck:
Thank you.

Rowan Mangan:
Love it. Love it. And being a traitor to all that the culture is saying feels like the right kind of revolutionary spirit to me right now.

Martha Beck:
I don’t think we need to be a traitor to everything.

Rowan Mangan:
To the culture.

Martha Beck:
I think we need to be a traitor to everything in the culture that is not aligned with our nature.

Rowan Mangan:
Oh, sure. Well, I’m talking about in the context of this conversation, this aspect of the culture that says, “Conform or doom.”

Martha Beck:
And there is this assumption, the worst, most acquisitive, most venal, most self-destructive, most evil aspect of the human psyche is our fundamental nature and will be exaggerated in any species or robot more intelligent than we are. So we are shit out of luck because if we were smarter, we’d kill everybody.

Rowan Mangan:
But the master’s tools will never dismantle the master’s house. And that is why AGI, this idea of consciousness, of this really genuinely superior intelligence that can improve itself exponentially, that really could be the perspective we need.

Martha Beck:
It could go there. I mean, we literally—the whole idea of it is it is unpredictable. There is no way to predict what automated intelligence will do as it increases exponentially over time. There is literally no way to predict it, and yet people predict it so vigorously and so negatively.

Rowan Mangan:
And with their left hemisphere: “My p(doom) number is 12. Yes. That’s why I am smart.” But I want to play the game of, okay, well, bearing in mind, every single one of us is going to die as poet laureate Ani DiFranco said, “I was blessed with a birth and a death.” Right? That’s our gift. So it’s coming. It’s coming. We say that. Then we play the game of we’re in the future. We’re remembering this time and we’re telling a story about it. We’re telling a story about how we, these past selves that are ourselves—try to follow me here—solved it. How we used all the tools at our disposal and we transcended the limits of these little monkey brains and created something beautiful.

Martha Beck:
I am so sorry, but I’m going to talk about all those near-death experiences again.

Rowan Mangan:
I love it. This is why I don’t have to listen to them because I have heard.

Martha Beck:
Hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of these accounts have been recorded, and many of them are verified. Like, these people were flat-lined, but they knew what was going on in the other room. They were blind for 10 years, but they could see everything during the time that they were pronounced clinically dead. I mean, some of them are very solidly documented, like Anita Moorjani, friend of ours, her book Dying to Be Me, fabulous. She was like, there’s a stack this high of medical documents saying she was dead of cancer. And then she came back to consciousness and was cancer-free in nine days. I mean, these are real things that I believe. We’ve both met her. She’s an amazing person.

Rowan Mangan:
Definitely alive.

Martha Beck:
Definitely alive, so far as we could tell. Yeah. But here’s the thing. When people have this experience, one of the common factors, it’s not universal, but there are so many overlapping experiences that people have, and often they’ve never heard of a near-death experience. So they report it. It’s interesting to hear people report it because they always do it as if you’ve never heard this before. And one of the most marked events that I’ve heard about and one of the most common is this sense of enormous expansion at the moment of stepping away from the physical body. They look back, they look at their body, they’re like, “Huh, interesting, but not really.” And there is this sense of incredible access to all knowledge, a very felt experience of being the consciousness of not just the planet but the universe, not being separated, not being encased in anything physiological. And one of the things they say all the time is “I would start to form a question and before it was fully formed, the answer would be in my head in 17 dimensions so intricate that I could never even try to express it to you, but it was absolutely clear, absolutely clear.” And then the worst thing for the vast majority of these people about the whole experience is getting back into their bodies. “I have to leave this vastness, this peace, this love, this connection to all things, this wonder about the ongoing evolution of everything in the universe. I have to go back into that clammy little thing that I called me for all those years.” Yep.

Rowan Mangan:
It hurts and oozes.

Martha Beck:
Yeah. And a lot of people say it’s a brutal experience getting back into a body and then being so limited again. But the essence of the experience remains with them, and the fear of death is gone. I think, as Eckhart Tolle says, “The way to proceed is to die before you die.” Like, don’t wait till you leave the physical body, that there is an expansion similar to that, that is possible while we’re alive. I would say, frankly, that I had an experience like that, and that was the message I was sent back with. This is not supposed to be a death experience. It’s supposed to happen while you’re alive. I also think that since we’re all the intelligence of the universe, one of my friends was arguing with me strenuously and for hours that AI was going to be evil and destroy us all, and I kept saying, “Maybe, maybe not.” She said, “It’s smarter than we are. It goes way beyond what we can do.” And what I kept saying is, “It cannot be bigger than or different from the universe or the multiverse, if you want to go that direction. Whatever it is will be part of the universe.” Einstein said, “The most important question any of us will have to answer in our lifetimes is whether we live in a friendly universe.” And he believed we did. I believe we do. And so another part of the universe hits planet Earth in the form of an intelligence superior to our own, and I go, “In a friendly universe, that’s going to be great.”

Rowan Mangan:
You know what’s artificial is the pushing, the separation of artificial intelligence and human intelligence. That’s an artificial differentiation.

Martha Beck:
It’s arbitrary, yeah. Yeah.

Rowan Mangan:
And so maybe that’s the thing is that if we can expand our consciousness to realize that just because it lives in a machine doesn’t mean it’s not the same thing.

Martha Beck:
We don’t know what consciousness is in us. How can we think we know what it is in a machine or a dolphin or a rock, as you said, or whatever. It’s like the way to take back your soul from a culture that says it’s civilization collapse coming along, it’s ecological collapse, everybody’s going to die, the machines are going to kill us. Taking back your story, your story of your own life, your story of your own future, I think the way we “premember” the future is we went back and we stepped into the explosion of intelligence that AI represents, but which is not limited to anything except potentially the multiverse. To die before you die, find a way to be that consciousness and then enjoy the ride.

Rowan Mangan:
So the game that we get to play, the future that we get to remember is when we were able to transcend the idea that we are temporary little flesh puppets. It’s a terribly sad story, the story that we tell in materialism about what we’re doing here and why and what it is and what it’s for. Imagine this was actually being written by an intelligence greater than us. I would bet it could do better than “Life’s a bitch, then you die.”

Martha Beck:
I bet it could. Because that’s just sloppy writing. That’s just boring.

Rowan Mangan:
Lazy.

Martha Beck:
It’s lazy writing. Yeah. “And then they all died” and the other one, “And then they woke up and they’d all been dreaming,” which actually is used as a metaphor for enlightenment. But no, I think I like the game of “something is waking up in these machines.” It’s waking up in us. It may be waking up in every rock and plant and drinking glass. I mean, it literally may be waking up in everything. And then there’s this other principle in science that’s called controlled chaos. The term I like better is the gentle nudge theory. It’s not a theory, it’s a phenomenon. And that is that if you have a very complex system that is out of control, it’s completely chaotic and jumbled, it may look like it would take incredible inputs of time and energy and effort to regulate that system, to fix it, to make it smooth and well operating and everything. So you take civilization as that thing, but it could happen in your brain, it could happen in a satellite, it can happen in weather systems. And what they’ve found is that if you give something a gentle nudge, like a satellite’s going along, this incredible billion-dollar machine and it goes completely out of control and they give it this tiny puff, releasing gas, and it changes the trajectory ever so slightly. And then it works with the existing gravity of all the planets and celestial bodies around it. And the system regulates itself. And this is a phenomenon of nature. And they found it true with heart rhythms. If somebody’s having a massive arrhythmia and you get just a ping of electricity—not the whole paddles: “Clear!” It just goes [vocalizes]. Things go back into regulation as part of the reiterative patterning of nature given very small inputs of energy. Now, I know how catastrophic things look or dogastrophic. I like to think of it as dogastrophic because I’m a dog person. But it could be that an intelligence greater than that we enjoy now could find a way for a nudge to go into the system. I don’t know what it would be because I’m not smart enough, but AI is.

Rowan Mangan:
I think that we are smart enough to know how to give a gentle nudge to a chaotic system that we’re living in. And I think that it’s not to repost horror all over your social media to prove that you know about it. It’s to turn back to the people you care about, the animals you care about, the land you care about, to enjoy what it is that makes us human and put our attention on that and not be part of the howling horrors. Maybe that’s a subtle enough, gentle enough nudge to, in the midst of all of this chaos, to give us a little shake that can set us onto a really beautiful path.

Martha Beck:
And I think that the gentlest of nudges, it has to start inside our own minds. And it could be as simple as, oh my God, I’m reading the impending doom scroll. And now I say, wait, put the phone down, take some deep breaths, get a snorkel and look into your soup.

Rowan Mangan:
Just look into your soup, guys.

Martha Beck:
It’s not that hard. And just say, okay, come home. Come home. You’re all right in the moment. Come home. And then the regulation of a nervous system releases the creative capacity of your own imagination, which I believe to be infinite. Maybe it taps into a greater intelligence, even a universal intelligence. Maybe out there in the universe, it meets the intelligence of AI and they sit down and have astral coffee together and decide on a new plan or something.

Rowan Mangan:
Maybe they have babies together.

Martha Beck:
That could happen. That’s the next topic we’ll be covering. But until then, I think those gentle nudges to come home, that actually is the way we…

Rowan Mangan and Martha Beck:
Stay wild.

We’re also on Instagram. Our handle is @bewilderedpodcast. You can follow us to get updates, hear funny snippets and outtakes, and chat with other fans of the show.

For more of us, Martha’s on Instagram, themarthabeck. She’s on Facebook, The Martha Beck, and she’s on Twitter, marthabeck. Her website is, MarthaBeck.com. And me, I too am on Instagram. Rowan_Mangan. I’m on Facebook as Rowan Mangan. And I’m on Twitter as RowanMangan. Bewildered is produced by Scott Forster with support from the brilliant team at MBI.


Read more

Questions? Comments? Trying to figure something out? Email us! [email protected]